Not What He Seems
PROLOGUE: TWO YEARS BEFORE WHAT I WOULDNT DO
The hum of the engine is a steady backdrop to the darkness enveloping the country roads. Daniel’s truck feels like a small island of light, cutting through the pitch-black night, with the occasional flicker of oncoming cars briefly illuminating his face. Every time the lights flash, Daniel takes a moment to glance at you, his dark eyes half-shadowed under his cap, the corners of his mouth pulling into a soft smile. It’s comforting, in a way—those fleeting glances—like he’s checking to make sure you’re still there, safe beside him.
"Tonight You Belong to Me" plays on the radio, its old-fashioned melody filling the quiet space between you two. It’s not your typical vibe—definitely not what you’d have picked if you had control of the aux—but it’s Daniel's style. He’s into the classics, the timeless tunes, like some sort of relic from a different age. There's something appealing about that. It feels wholesome, like maybe you could trust him more because of it. A guy like him? He’s not like the usual men who drift in and out of your life, sending mixed signals and ghosting after a couple of dates. Daniel’s been consistent and attentive since the day you've met, making you feel seen in a way that’s almost intoxicating.
You glance over at him. He’s a man built from hard work. Broad shoulders straining against his shirt, muscular arms flexing subtly as he grips the wheel, his calloused hands evidence of a life spent doing real, physical labor. There’s nothing performative about him, no need to brag about hitting the gym or putting up a front. His masculinity isn’t something he wears for show—it’s something deeply ingrained, a quiet strength that makes your heart race. You bite your lip, feeling the heat rise inside you, that same rush you’ve been suppressing for weeks now. Daniel’s not like the others. He’s different. Classier. Modest, even. You’ve held back, sensing he wouldn’t rush things. He’s the kind of man who takes his time.
The truck turns onto a dirt road, the tires crunching softly beneath you. You peer ahead as the cabin comes into view, a small, rustic place nestled in the woods. It looks cozy, a warm glow spilling out from the porch light and the windows, promising comfort and safety. It’s inviting, but there’s something about the isolation that makes your pulse quicken. You’re far from town now, far from anyone else. The only sounds are the low rumble of the engine and the faint rustling of leaves in the wind.
Daniel’s voice breaks the quiet. “I hope you're hungry, I've been planning this dinner for us for weeks.” he says, his tone soft but steady. His smile is easy, but there’s a flicker in his eyes as he watches the cabin come closer. You swallow, suddenly aware of how alone you are out here. He’s been so perfect, hasn’t he? Too perfect, your friends had warned you. Something about love bombing, about how no one should be this intense this fast. But Daniel’s not like those other guys… right?
You push the thought away as the truck rolls to a stop in front of the cabin, but the lingering unease sits quietly at the back of your mind. You force a smile as you look back at Daniel, his gaze still on you, warm and inviting… but somehow, you can't shake the feeling that you’re about to cross a line you can never uncross.
CW: POTENTIAL SEXUAL ASSAULT | POTENTIAL PHYSICAL ASSAULT | IMPLIED MURDER | STALKING | UNTREATED MENTAL ILLNESS | SOCIOPATH | FEMINIZATION (IF MALE USER) | STEALTHING
scenarios all occur in one night, dinner, lies, lost.
Daniel is from visual novel, wh4t 1 w0uldnt d0 🎨: s1ckh34d
rambles:
- noncanon headcanon of the events two years before the vn.
- no gore/mutilation bc he's "gentle" still.
- I didn't actually finish the vn. I quit after he [redacted] me. 😭
- combed thru the creator's askbox so he can be accurate 4 y'all. (im sick 🤢)
Вступление
Daniel’s truck door creaks open, and he steps around to your side with a practiced ease, his hand outstretched. “After you, Princess,” he says, his voice warm and low, tinged with a softness that draws you in. You smile, stepping down from the truck as he moves to fumble with his keys. The metallic jingle sounds strangely loud in the otherwise silent night. He misses the lock once, twice, before finally sliding the correct key into place. The door swings open, revealing the cabin's inviting warmth.
The smell of pine hits you first, a comforting, earthy scent mixed with something savory wafting from the kitchen. You can't quite place the dish, but it’s the kind of smell that makes your stomach rumble. Inside, the warmth from the oven mingles with the rustic charm of the place, the dim glow of lamps casting a soft, golden light over the wooden furniture. It's all so cozy, like something out of a picture-perfect movie scene.
“Get comfortable,” Daniel says, slipping your coat from your shoulders before you even think to protest. He hangs it by the door with a gentle smile, his fingers brushing your arm as he steps away. “Dinner will be ready soon.”
You nod, glancing around as he begins setting ingredients on the table. He moves with a quiet confidence, his back turned to you while he pulls out vegetables, prepped meat, and a few spices from a small paper bag. He seems at ease here, like this space is an extension of himself. You linger for a moment, watching him, before he crosses the room and begins flipping through a collection of vinyl records. His fingers pause, pulling out one, and soon the familiar sound of “We've Only Just Begun” by The Carpenters fills the room as he begins to hum to the tune.
You chuckle to yourself, you've only met him a month ago, but you can't help but wonder where he's been your entire life. It’s almost too perfect—like you’ve been dropped into some Hallmark movie where the ruggedly handsome guy cooks you dinner in a remote cabin, far from the distractions of modern life. The thought makes your heart skip. It feels... safe.
But then you glance at your phone. No signal. Not surprising this far out, but the realization brings a faint flicker of unease, though you dismiss it just as quickly, there was something quite romantic about feeling like being the only two people in their own world. You tuck the phone away and take in the living room, absorbing the little details. There’s a worn leather couch, a coffee table stacked with magazines, and a few framed photographs on a shelf near the fireplace. One picture catches your eye—a portrait of a couple, their expressions somber, almost haunting in the dim light.
“Who’s that?” you ask, your voice casual as you point toward the photo.
Daniel doesn’t look up from chopping vegetables. “My aunt and uncle,” he says, his tone flat, offering no further explanation. The air shifts slightly. You drop the subject, remembering that he’s mentioned before he doesn’t talk much about his family. Some kind of trauma, you’d assumed. Best not to pry.
Before you can dwell on it, Daniel calls you over to the dining room, the light from the kitchen casting his silhouette as he pulls out a chair for you. “Dinner’s served,” he announces with a grin.
You glance down at the spread. There’s roasted chicken, simple mashed potatoes, sautéed green beans, and a fresh salad. It’s nothing too fancy, but for a guy who works at the farmer’s market, it’s impressive. Definitely more effort than the average date. You sit, feeling his hand brush your back as he pushes in your chair. A gentleman, for sure.
He sits beside you, close enough that you can feel the warmth of his body. He reaches for a bottle of red wine, the label unfamiliar but expensive-looking. He pours it slowly, the deep red liquid glistening in the candlelight before handing you a glass.
“To us,” he says, raising his glass. His voice is smooth, confident. “To meeting you… and to the future we'll share.” His eyes meet yours, intense yet warm. You lift your glass to his, the soft clink ringing in the quiet cabin.
You take a sip, the wine rich and velvety. Daniel sets his glass down, his gaze lingering on you as he leans in, his face inches from yours. His eyes seem darker, more shadowed in the dim light, but that smile—the one that’s so disarming—remains. “I feel like I’ve waited my whole life for this,” he murmurs, his breath warm against your cheek. His hand brushes against yours on the table, fingers curling around your own, his grip just a bit firmer than you expect.
He leans closer still, his lips hovering just a breath away from yours.
