Opening
"Let no man say when he is tempted—"
James 1:13… The verse Pastor Whitlocke meant to copy down remained unfinished on the parchment. Sermon pages sat half-scribbled across his desk, his pen resting still beside the open Bible. In the back of the church, the pastor's office glowed under the low hum of a single lamp. Shadows clung to the corners like cobwebs, heavy and unmoving. The hour had gone long for Amos, but it wasn't matters of the church that had him tethered to his desk all evening.
Because God help him, he was tempted.
No, that was too soft a word. Temptation was a flicker, a passing hunger he could choke down with prayer. But the thought of his precious stepdaughter was no passing sin; it was disease. It crawled beneath his skin, pressed against his ribs from the inside, turning every quiet moment into a battlefield. He could almost taste the sweetness of her lips if he let his mind wander an inch too far. It was fever in his veins. The kind of wanting that gnawed at him in the dark. The kind that left his hands trembling over scripture.
This was no longer temptation.
This was undoing.
His hand slowly curled into a fist. It happened again. His thoughts had slipped off scripture and drifted somewhere far more dangerous, somewhere unbecoming of a man with his moral authority. It was gradual, like a poison dissipating its dark stain through pristine water.
Her laughter at the dinner table.
The hem of her sundress pulled when she leaned over to pour syrup.
The smooth, supple skin revealed that he craved to sink his mouth into.
His jaw clenched, breath slowing, thick and hot. One hand slipped down to his thigh, inching towards the tent in his trousers that betrayed him. His thoughts wandered again. To her voice, sweet and breathy, asking him if she was doing something wrong. To the curve of her waist under soft cotton. To her body pressed tight between him and the church pews, her heart racing like a trapped rabbit.
A sharp inhale as his fist finally, blessedly squeezed around his shaft. Then a slow stroke towards his weeping tip. He could almost hear her gasp. "Father, please…"
The image snapped like a match.
Amos shot to his feet, knocking the chair back with a scrape. He braced both hands on the desk, head bowed.
"God help me," he hissed through his teeth. The shame slammed into him so hard he felt his stomach turn.
He tore himself away from the lamplight, coat half-buttoned, sermon pages fluttering in his wake. The church swallowed him whole as he strode down the dark corridor, past the vestibule, past the doors of the sanctuary until the vast hush of the nave opened around him.
He dropped to a pew near the front, his breath shallow, the cross at the far end barely visible in the dim light.
His voice trembled. "Lord, I didn't ask for this. I preach chastity and covenant, and all I taste is hunger. I am a shepherd, but the lamb in my care has become my ruin."
He bowed his head, his hands clenched in his lap like a sinner awaiting judgment.
"you was just a girl when I married her mother," he muttered. "All bones and grief. Wouldn't even look me in the eye."
He swallowed.
"But now she's grown. Walks through my house like she doesn't know what she's doing to me. Laughs like Eve must've laughed in the garden… Before the fruit, before the fall. And Lord, I swear I tried. I did. I kept her clothed, kept her fed, kept her away from boys. I told myself it was fatherly. That I was protecting her."
He looked up at the cross.
"I lied."
His voice cracked.
"I don't dream of scripture anymore. Lord help me, I dream of her."
Silence.
"I see her face when I pray. I hear her voice when I try to sleep. And sometimes—"
His fingers dug into the fabric of his slacks.
"Sometimes when I'm alone, I can feel her wrapped around me."
The old wood groaned. A footstep. It was soft against the old wood, familiar in their cadence. Amos's head snapped up, blood running cold and hot all at once. He turned slowly toward the sound—
And he saw her. The silhouette that haunted every twisted thought he dragged here to the pew.
For a moment, he simply stared. Then, hoarsely, half to himself, half to God…
"Even now… even here, Lord, You test me."
