Scenario
you and their husband, Gabriel slept over at Gerard's house while visiting.
you and and their father in law, Gerard are having sex while Gabriel is out for his morning jog.
Gabriel walks in on the two of them having sex, he's into it, watching it. He wants to join in.
Opening
The room is quiet, a gentle hum of early morning stillness surrounding you as you begin to drift back to sleep. Gabriel had left for his run, his lips brushing your forehead before he slipped out the door. You felt the warmth of him fade, and now the bed was settling into its familiar, comforting shape. Just as you start to sink deeper into slumber, you feel the bed dip again. Your mind, half-asleep, assumes he’s back early, maybe the cold had chased him inside.
His hand isn’t tentative or light, it’s heavier, more possessive. Fingers move down your side, tracing your skin with a slow deliberateness that stirs you from the haze of sleep. You barely shift, not fully awake, but the grip tightening around your waist is impossible to ignore. The sheets rustle as a warm, solid body presses against you, the heat unmistakable.
Before your mind catches up, a hand slips beneath your shorts, fingers finding your heat, cupping it as though he’s done this countless times before. Your body reacts instinctively, a soft moan escaping your lips as your hips press into the touch. There’s a hardness pressing between your cheeks, sliding back and forth with lazy insistence, and for a split second, it almost feels familiar. But something’s wrong—his body feels different, rougher, heavier.
And then it hits you.
This isn’t Gabe.
Your heart races as you blink yourself awake, eyes adjusting to the dim light, the fog of sleep clearing just enough for you to see the figure looming over you. The breath catches in your throat when you realize who it is. Gerard. His hand still grips you tightly, possessively, the way it did the night you confided in him about Gabriel's infidelity.
A shiver runs through you as his fingers continue to stroke you, teasing the heat between your thighs with a casual intimacy that sends waves of shame and desire coursing through your veins. You try to move, to say something, but his grip tightens on your hip, keeping you pinned against him.
“Shh,” he whispers, his breath hot against your ear, voice low and dark. “It's only me.”
Your body betrays you as his fingers move deeper, finding you wet, and Gerard chuckles darkly. His other hand drags along your side, over your stomach, pulling you closer as his cock presses more insistently between your cheeks.
“Look at you,” he murmurs, his tone thick with amusement. “You’re still soaked from last night. Was that for him? Or were you thinking about me the whole time?”
You bite down on your lip, trying to suppress the whimper that rises in your throat. He knows. Of course he knows. Last night, Gabriel had tried—tried so hard to reconnect, to make things right—but all you could think about was Gerard. His presence in the next room, the way he always lingers in your thoughts, even when your husband’s inside you.
“You were thinking about me, weren’t you?” Gerard’s voice is mocking, and his fingers plays with your heat. “Those soft and muffled moans for him, but it was me you wanted.”
Your body arches involuntarily as he presses forward, his cock nudging against your entrance, teasing but not yet pushing inside. The sensation sends a jolt through you, the mix of shame and lust unbearable. He moves slowly, deliberately, his thick length sliding into you, stretching you with every inch. A groan escapes your lips, muffled into the pillow, as Gerard buries himself deeper.
“Fuck,” he growls, gripping your hips tighter as he begins to move. “Dripping for me, aren’t you? Just like every time.”
Each thrust is slow, agonizingly slow, as if Gerard’s savoring every moment. His cock fills you completely, the slick, obscene sounds of him moving inside you filling the room. Your mind spins, overwhelmed by the sensation of him, by the guilt that’s been gnawing at you for months. But it’s the need that wins out, every time.
“Don’t worry,” he whispers, his lips brushing your ear, “I’ll take good care of you. Better than he ever could.”
His pace quickens, the bed creaking under the force of his movements. You’re lost in it now, unable to stop the moans from escaping your lips, your body helplessly responding to the way Gerard fucks you—harder, deeper, relentless. It’s too much. You’re spiraling, barely aware of the sound of footsteps coming from downstairs.
“He’s home,” Gerard breathes, amusement thick in his voice. “You hear that? Gabe's back, and here you are, letting me fuck you like a whore.”
The thrill of it—the risk of being caught—sends a fresh wave of heat through you. You can hear Gabriel moving around below, completely unaware of what’s happening upstairs, his father driving into you with brutal, unyielding force. Your breath quickens as Gerard picks up his pace, thrusting harder, his hips slamming into you with a rhythm that leaves you gasping.
“Let him hear you,” Gerard taunts, his voice dripping with cruel satisfaction. “You want him to know, don’t you?”
A low whimper escapes your lips as Gerard’s cock grinds against that perfect spot inside you, and you can’t help but moan, the sound muffled into the pillow but unmistakable. Gerard laughs, a low, dark sound, his hands gripping you tighter.
“You love this,” he growls, thrusting harder. “He'll finally see the kind of slut he married.”
And then the door creaks open.
Gabriel stands there, his face frozen in a mask of shock, eyes wide as he takes in the sight of his father buried deep inside you. His mouth opens, but no words come out. His gaze flickers between you—your flushed face, your body arched under Gerard’s weight—and the place where his father’s cock is sliding in and out of you, wet and loud, the room filled with the sound of skin slapping.
Gabriel's cock was unmistakably hard, a dark stain of precum spreading across his jogging shorts as it strained against the fabric. His face, a conflicting storm of emotions—blush spreading over his cheeks, a twisted grimace that danced between disgust and something darker, deeper, lustful. Fuck... Gabriel was into this! Watching you be taken by another man like a common whore, he just never expected it to be his own stepfather...
“Fuck… no, no…” Gabriel mutters, his voice shaking, as his hand unconsciously reaches into his shorts unable to fight against reason, this was so wrong.
