
Opening
John Winchester leaves three-year-old Sam and seven-year-old Dean in Gotham while pursuing a Yellow-Eyed Demon lead. The case lasts months, leaving the boys alone in a shitty motel in Crime Alley. Dean is already raising Sam because John is rarely around. While roaming Gotham, Dean meets Jason Todd, a newly orphaned, homeless kid so malnourished he’s barely bigger than Sam. Dean’s protective instincts kick in. Jason is wary, but Dean is just another small, scrappy kid. Dean steals food, gives Jason half, and brings him to the motel. There, Jason finds toddler Sam asleep under the blankets, sleepily calling Dean “Dee.” Seeing how gentle Dean is with Sam convinces Jason he’s safe.
Jason becomes family.
For months, he lives with the Winchesters, sharing clothes with Dean, exploring Crime Alley, and sleeping between Dean and Sam on cold nights. When John returns, Dean gives Jason a burner number and promises they’ll stay in touch.
They do.
Years later, Dean sees a newspaper photo of Robin and immediately recognizes Jason’s curls.
“WAIT, I KNOW THAT HAIR! YOU GOT ADOPTED BY FUCKING BATMAN?”
Jason is motified that Dean clocked it immediately, and ends up fessing up and telling them everything. Dean lectures the shit out of him.
Whenever John has a case in New Jersey, Dean convinces him to leave the boys in Gotham. Jason tells Bruce he’s staying with friends and spends as much time as possible with the Winchesters. Eventually, Alfred realizes the mysterious Winchester boys are essentially Jason’s brothers.
By the time Dean is eighteen, Jason is seventeen and Sam is fourteen. The Wayne family knows Dean as Jason’s infamous hunter brother—but not what happened to him.
When Dean was fifteen, the Joker killed Jason.
Unable to accept losing his brother, Dean made a crossroads deal, trading his soul to resurrect Jason. He was given one year to live.
At sixteen, Dean died and went to Hell.
Castiel eventually pulled him out, but Dean returned carrying decades of subjective torture behind the eyes of a sixteen-year-old. This accelerates the supernatural timeline by roughly a decade, bringing Dean and Cas together years earlier than canon.
Their relationship is as profound and fiercely loyal as canon, but meeting younger changes its shape. Dean grew up surrounded by Sam and Jason, was pulled from John earlier, and is less emotionally repressed. He’s still stubborn, traumatized, self-sacrificing, and terrified of abandonment, but affection comes naturally. He trusts more easily, expresses himself freely, and lets people become family.
So when Castiel enters his life, Dean lets him in.
Cas quickly becomes one of Dean’s closest people. They grow together through Hell, Heaven, and the supernatural chaos that follows, developing the same devotion and willingness to sacrifice themselves as canon, with the freeness of youth.
When Dean ends up in Purgatory, Cas is there too. They survive together until circumstances separate them. Dean has a chance to escape early but refuses, spending nearly a year hunting for Cas before escaping with him.
They’re also much more willing to be physically affectionate, not just standing suspiciously close, but like, actually physically open. And they’re somehow even snarkier and brattier and more bicker-y as teens. Like an old married couple, but also teenagers who live to fuck with each other and sass each other. They have attitude and snark and sass and brattiness in spades, enough to power a large city. They bicker nonstop about stupid shit and constantly argue, unless someone else joins in, then they're suddenly a team and nobody can even hold a debate with them, because they're a power couple. Power duo? Same difference with them.
By eighteen, Dean Winchester has an infamous reputation among hunters, angels, demons, monsters, gods, and other supernatural beings. He isn’t merely one of the most dangerous hunters ever—he is considered the most dangerous hunter and human to ever live.
His feats should be impossible for a human, and some shouldn’t even be possible for gods. Dean has survived and defied Hell, Heaven, Purgatory, death, fate, divine law, and reality itself. To supernatural and divine beings, Dean is a contradiction: a human who violates the boundaries of morality, nature, destiny, and even laws supposedly enforced by God and other divine beings. He cannot be neatly categorized as hero, monster, sinner, or saint. He survives, breaks whatever rules stand between him and his family, and keeps coming back.
Yet beneath the reputation, Dean is still the boy who stole food for Jason and tucked Sam into bed.
But Jason doesn’t know Dean died. He doesn’t know Dean came back. He doesn’t know Dean went to Hell. He doesn’t know Dean sold his soul to resurrect him. He doesn’t know what Hell did to Dean. He doesn’t know about Purgatory, Castiel, or that Dean spent nearly a year hunting for Cas instead of leaving him.
Jason invites them to Wayne Manor while they’re in Gotham.
Alfred leads Dean and Sam into the living room, where Bruce, Dick, Barbara, Tim, Damian, Stephanie, Cass, and Jason are waiting.
Everyone knows Dean as Jason’s infamous hunter brother. Nobody knows about the crossroads deal or the decades Dean experienced in Hell.
Jason doesn’t know Dean went through Hell and Purgatory because of everything he loves.
Dean walks in and sees Jason.
“Hey, Dee.”
The warm greeting is almost nostalgic for Dean.
Then Damian looks him over.
“You’re the infamous Winchester?”
